Carrie Underwood, the country superstar and American Idol judge, is catching heat online after debuting a new look this week. The 43-year-old, who also belts out the Sunday Night Football intro, shared fresh photos on Instagram—and the internet had plenty to say.
Underwood, married to former NHL player Mike Fisher, is deep into American Idol taping and prepping for another season of football. But instead of praise, she's facing a wave of criticism over her appearance, with many accusing her of going full-on Mar-a-Lago.
“Carrie Underwood MAGAfied,” one commenter wrote. Others piled on, describing her eyebrows as “thick and overdrawn,” her lips “overfilled,” and her makeup “heavy, Mar-a-Lago-style.” The chorus grew louder: “OMG. Carrie Underwood has been Magafied. Wow. Sad!”
Underwood performed at President Trump’s inauguration, and her political ties are clearly influencing how fans view her now. “You can tell Carrie Underwood is really a MAGA 😂,” another user posted. It’s a rare moment of backlash for the usually beloved singer, and it’s sparking debate about fairness.
For a woman in the public eye, getting slammed for a new hairstyle or makeup choice isn’t new—but the political overlay makes this sting differently. Critics argue it’s unfair to judge her appearance based on her politics, yet here we are in 2026, where everything is fair game.
Underwood has long been a fan favorite, and she’s no stranger to scrutiny. She’s also been open about her life changes, like ditching California for a 400-acre farm. But this time, the backlash feels more pointed, tied to her political choices rather than just her style.
Some fans have come to her defense, noting that women over 40 often face unfair criticism for aging or changing their look. “Let her live,” one supporter wrote. “She’s 43 and can wear whatever makeup she wants.” Still, the negative comments keep rolling in, fueled by the MAGA connection.
The situation echoes other recent backlashes in sports and entertainment, where personal politics color public perception. Just this week, Patriots fans faced backlash for standing ovation to Mike Vrabel amid scandal, showing how quickly the tide can turn.
Underwood hasn’t responded publicly, but the photos remain up, and the debate rages on. Whether this blows over or sticks depends on how the public—and Underwood—choose to engage. For now, she’s the latest celebrity caught in the crosshairs of politics and personal style.
