The search for Nancy Guthrie, mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie, has taken a contentious turn—and former ESPN star Jemele Hill is not holding back her frustration.
Guthrie, 84, disappeared from her Arizona home on January 31. Family members say she was taken in the middle of the night, and despite a nationwide search, authorities have offered few updates. The case has now drawn sharp criticism from both the FBI and outspoken sports commentator Jemele Hill.
FBI Director Calls Out Local Police
FBI Director Kash Patel revealed on Fox News that his agency was sidelined early in the investigation. Speaking with Sean Hannity, Patel said, “What we, the FBI, do is say, ‘Hey, we’re here to help. What do you need?’ And for four days, we were kept out of the investigation.”
Patel described having resources ready to deploy—including a fixed-wing aircraft—only to be told the plane was sent to Florida instead. “They have jurisdiction, so it’s their call,” he said, implying the delay may have cost crucial time.
Hill Sounds Off on Social Media
Jemele Hill, never one to stay silent on issues of justice, took to social media after reports surfaced that the FBI had launched a criminal leak investigation into journalist Sarah Fitzpatrick, who wrote a critical piece about Patel’s work habits. Hill responded sharply, questioning the bureau’s priorities.
“The FBI has launched a criminal leak investigation focusing on Atlantic magazine journalist Sarah Fitzpatrick, who wrote that deeply unflattering account of Kash Patel’s work habits,” reported Kyle Griffin. Hill’s reply made clear she believes the Guthrie case deserves far more urgency than internal leaks.
Hill has a history of calling out what she sees as double standards in sports and media. She previously blasted NFL Media for its handling of the Russini fallout, and she torched the WNBA commissioner's defense of league policies. Her latest outburst suggests she sees the Guthrie case as yet another example of institutional failure.
A Family’s Agony, a Nation Watching
Nancy Guthrie, described by loved ones as a devoted grandmother, was last seen on January 31. Authorities still believe she could be alive, but the lack of progress has left the family desperate for answers. The Pima County Sheriff’s Department has not commented on Patel’s allegations.
Hill’s frustration echoes a growing public sentiment that the investigation has been mishandled. As the search drags into its fourth month, the question remains: why was the FBI initially shut out?
For now, Hill—and many others—are watching closely, hoping the case finally gets the attention it deserves.
