Saturday's College GameDay crew had to eat a big slice of humble pie after Wake Forest dismantled SMU in a 49-7 blowout. Kirk Herbstreit and Pat McAfee, the show's star analysts, took to social media to issue a joint apology for doubting the Demon Deacons.
"Whelp. Both @PatMcAfeeShow and I want apologize from the bottom of our hearts for picking against @WakeFB We thought SMU at home had a chance and BOY WE WE WRONG!! These boys are for real! Congrats and WE BELIEVE!" Herbstreit posted on X.
McAfee echoed the sentiment with a simple, self-deprecating post: "That's 100% ON US."
The apology came after Wake Forest improved to 9-1 on the season, making a serious case for a College Football Playoff berth. The Demon Deacons' dominant performance at SMU was a statement win, and the college football world took notice.
Fans were quick to react, with many appreciating the accountability. "Kirk has always been anti-wake, so this is a welcome apology," one fan wrote. Another was less forgiving: "You never respected us. Don't hop on the train now boys."
Some fans even suggested that GameDay should head to Winston-Salem for the upcoming Duke-Wake Forest matchup, while others simply enjoyed the on-air chemistry between Herbstreit and McAfee, with one fan noting, "You guys are truly awesome together. Peter included. Lol."
This isn't the first time Herbstreit has been in the spotlight this season. He recently delivered a moving Veterans Day tribute that resonated with fans, and his bond with his late dog Ben continues to touch hearts, as seen in a recent reflection. Meanwhile, McAfee has been a polarizing figure, with critics and defenders alike, as highlighted by Dan Dakich's defense of the former punter.
But on Saturday, the two put aside any off-field debates to own up to their on-air miss. It's a refreshing dose of humility from two of ESPN's biggest personalities, and it shows that even the experts can be wrong.
For Wake Forest, the victory was another step in a remarkable season. The Demon Deacons are now firmly in the playoff conversation, and they'll look to keep their momentum rolling as the regular season winds down and the College Football Playoff approaches.
As for Herbstreit and McAfee, they've learned a valuable lesson: never count out the Demon Deacons. With a 9-1 record and a dominant win over a ranked opponent, Wake Forest has proven they're for real — and they've earned the respect of even their biggest doubters.



