The College Football Playoff selection committee dropped its latest top 25 on Tuesday, and as usual, the reaction was swift and loud. But this week, the loudest noise came from those who believe the committee gave Ohio State a major gift.
The Buckeyes, who had to grind out a 28-19 victory over a struggling Northwestern squad, somehow climbed six spots to No. 14 in the updated rankings. That leap, coming after a game where Ohio State looked far from dominant and following two losses in their last three outings, left fans and analysts scratching their heads.
“Ohio State wins by 9 vs. Northwestern, moves up 6 spots?” Brett McMurphy of On3 posted on X, echoing a sentiment shared widely across social media.
Quinn Douglas of KQWC Radio was even more direct: “Ohio State ahead of Iowa is baffling.” The Hawkeyes, who have been steady all season, found themselves behind the Buckeyes in the new rankings, a decision that many see as a classic case of blue blood bias.
“Blue blood bias garbage, Iowa gets jumped by both Oregon and Ohio State,” one fan fumed. Another simply said, “Ohio State at 14 is wild.”
The committee’s decision is particularly controversial because Ohio State’s resume doesn't exactly scream playoff-worthy. They've lost to Oregon and Michigan, and their best wins are against teams that are currently unranked or barely ranked. Yet, with the new 12-team playoff format, a spot in the field is not out of reach if the Buckeyes win out.
As ESPN still sees a path for Ohio State to crash the playoff, the team controls its own destiny, but the path is narrow. They must win their remaining regular-season games and then make a strong run in the Big Ten title game.
Fans, however, are not convinced that Ohio State deserves the benefit of the doubt. The Week 12 AP Poll chaos is already brewing, with many arguing that teams like Iowa and even Indiana have stronger cases for a higher ranking.
The CBS 12-team playoff forecast after Week 11 had Ohio State on the outside looking in, but the committee's move suggests they see something different. As the season winds down, every ranking will be scrutinized, and this one has certainly set off a firestorm.
For now, Ohio State is ranked No. 14, and the Buckeyes have a legitimate shot at the playoff. But as fans have made clear, they don't think that shot is deserved.



