There's a fine line between spirited debate and outright pettiness, and Ohio State fans are convinced ESPN analyst Desmond Howard has sprinted past it. The former Michigan star has spent the past two weeks taking thinly veiled shots at Buckeyes wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, and the patience of Buckeye Nation has officially run dry.
It all started last week when Howard appeared on First Take and questioned whether Smith deserved Heisman Trophy consideration. Howard argued that while Smith's stats are impressive, he hasn't delivered a defining performance in a high-stakes game.
“You got to have those moments,” Howard said. “In the last two seasons, when was Jeremiah Smith the difference in a big game? Give me that game. As much as he puts up these magnificent numbers, I need moments against the top competition that shows he’s the guy.”
Fast forward to this week, and Howard seemingly doubled down. While discussing Utah quarterback Devon Dampier, Howard praised the signal-caller for showing up in “big games.” To many, it was another not-so-subtle dig at Smith. The reaction from Ohio State fans was swift and unforgiving.
“They need to shut him up,” one fan fumed on social media. “Why keep him on the show?” another asked. The frustration isn't just about one comment—it's a pattern that has worn thin.
Even some who share Howard's alma mater are tired of his act. “I’m a Michigan fan but I can’t stand Desmond’s inability to recognize greatness,” one user wrote. The criticism has grown so loud that ESPN is facing calls to remove Howard from its college football coverage altogether.
Heisman Winners Rally Behind Smith
Howard's critiques have not gone unanswered. Former Baylor star Robert Griffin III, a Heisman winner himself, publicly called out Howard's bias.
“Well, he showed up in big games all over the place,” Griffin said. “Desmond Howard has to stop hating on Jeremiah Smith just because he goes to Ohio State. That’s not the right way, and you got to be better in our Heisman brotherhood.”
Griffin isn't alone. Mark Ingram, another Heisman recipient, has thrown his full support behind Smith. “My leader is Jeremiah Smith. He’s the one who gets my vote,” Ingram said. “You talk about the best player in college football, it’s Jeremiah Smith. What happens when Julian Sayin goes down? Don’t worry, he’s still productive. All he does is make big plays.”
It's not just analysts and former players who are weighing in. The Buckeyes' recent playoff ranking has already sparked outrage among fans, and Howard's comments have added fuel to the fire. Some are even pointing to the antics on College GameDay as a distraction from the actual football.
At this point, it's clear that Howard's relationship with Ohio State fans is beyond repair. Whether ESPN will listen to the backlash remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Buckeye Nation is done with the drama.



