The heat is rising on ESPN to cut ties with longtime "College GameDay" analyst Desmond Howard after his latest remarks about Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith sparked a firestorm of criticism. The backlash, fueled by Buckeyes fans and even fellow analysts, has turned into a broader conversation about Howard's professionalism and his history of questionable takes involving Ohio State.
Howard, a Heisman winner from Michigan, doubled down on his assertion that Smith shouldn't be in the Heisman conversation because he hasn't been a difference-maker in big games. Appearing on "First Take," Howard challenged critics to name a single game where Smith was the deciding factor against top competition over the past two seasons, despite Smith's jaw-dropping stats and highlight-reel catches.
Fans were quick to remind Howard of Smith's game-winning touchdown grab in the College Football Playoff national title game against Notre Dame in January 2025—a moment that perfectly counters the narrative. The backlash was swift, with Robert Griffin III publicly calling out Howard for what he described as "hating" on Smith simply because he plays for Ohio State. Griffin urged Howard to stop letting personal bias cloud his analysis.
Howard fired back with a heated response on social media, accusing Griffin of manufacturing beef for attention and challenging him to a face-to-face debate. He insisted his critique was purely football-based and not an attack on Smith's character or school. But the damage was done, and the criticism only intensified.
This isn't the first time Howard has drawn ire for his treatment of Ohio State. During the 2021 Heisman ceremony, he took a thinly veiled shot at the Buckeyes' offensive line right in front of quarterback C.J. Stroud. He later apologized, calling it "good-natured ribbing," but many fans haven't forgotten. In 2023, Howard also publicly questioned ESPN reporter Pete Thamel's role on "College GameDay," mocking him in a way that many deemed unprofessional.
The latest controversy has reignited calls for ESPN to take action. Fans have taken to social media to voice their frustration, with some arguing that Howard shouldn't be employed after his treatment of Thamel, while others label his behavior "unprofessional." Former Ohio State star Bobby Carpenter didn't hold back, calling Howard's comments "gross" and expressing gratitude that RGIII spoke up.
Despite the mounting pressure, ESPN has yet to respond publicly. The network has stood by Howard since he joined in 2005, but with each incident, the question grows louder: How much longer will they tolerate this behavior? The situation has also put a spotlight on the broader issue of analyst accountability in sports media.
As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: Desmond Howard's future at ESPN is uncertain, and the network may soon have to make a difficult decision. Whether they choose to part ways or stand by their analyst, the fallout is far from over.



