The U.S. men's national team is on the hunt for a new head coach after Mauricio Pochettino packed his bags for Manchester United. Names like Pep Guardiola and Jürgen Klopp have been tossed around, but one former USMNT midfielder turned broadcaster has a different idea—and it's raising eyebrows from coast to coast.
Kyle Martino, now a TNT Sports analyst, floated a provocative suggestion: why not hand the reins of the men's team to Emma Hayes, the current manager of the U.S. women's national team? "I got a name for you guys. And this isn't clickbait, this is a conversation starter," Martino said on air. "I'm sure the trolls are gonna come out from underneath their bridges, get their thumbs busy. Emma Hayes. Hear me out here."
Hayes, who led Chelsea to multiple Women's Super League titles before taking over the USWNT, is widely regarded as one of the top coaches in the global game. Martino argues her pedigree and relationship with U.S. Soccer make her a viable candidate—even if she'd be juggling two of the most demanding jobs in the sport. "Emma Hayes is one of the best coaches in the world," he said. "She's got an incredible resume. She's done it abroad, she's done it here, she has a great relationship with U.S. Soccer, great relationship with the fans. We have equal pay for our players. We were a country that led the charge there with other nations. Let's lead the charge in equal opportunities."
The idea of one coach overseeing both senior national teams isn't entirely unprecedented in other sports, but in soccer, where the men's and women's games operate on different schedules and tactical landscapes, it would be a logistical nightmare. Still, Martino's point about equal opportunity has sparked a broader conversation about gender barriers in coaching. As the sports world continues to evolve—much like the expanded College Football Playoff—the notion of a woman leading a men's national team is no longer unthinkable.
Reaction on social media was swift and brutal. "This is America. We have one of our greatest former players saying Pep is a bad hire while another ex player is begging for attention with brain dead takes saying to hire someone with no experience in the men's game. Pathetic," one fan wrote. Another added, "Kyle this may be the most embarrassing take I have ever heard in my life & this is why we're taken seriously." A third chimed in, "This is the single dumbest thing I've ever heard, our country needs real people in charge of our soccer federation." And perhaps the most cutting: "This is why the football world will never take Americans seriously."
While the critics are loud, Hayes herself has yet to comment on the speculation. She's currently focused on preparing the USWNT for upcoming international windows. The men's team, meanwhile, is reportedly considering a shortlist of high-profile candidates, including former Real Madrid boss Zinedine Zidane and current free agent Joachim Löw. But Martino's proposal isn't about the shortlist—it's about challenging conventional wisdom.
Could Hayes actually handle both jobs? The schedules for the men's and women's teams rarely overlap, but the scouting, player management, and media obligations would be immense. Some argue that splitting her attention could shortchange both programs. Others see it as a revolutionary step toward equality. As Martino put it, "Let's lead the charge in equal opportunities."
Whether or not U.S. Soccer entertains the idea, the debate itself highlights a shifting landscape. Women coaches are breaking barriers in men's professional leagues—just look at the NBA's recent trend of hiring female assistants, or the NFL's growing number of women in coaching roles. The soccer world, however, remains stubbornly traditional. But as the NFL's coaching carousel shows, fresh thinking can sometimes pay off.
For now, Hayes remains the undisputed leader of the USWNT, and the men's job is still vacant. But Martino's hot take has done its job: it got people talking. And in the 24/7 sports news cycle, that's often half the battle. Whether it's a genius idea or a fool's errand, one thing is clear—Emma Hayes is a name that will keep coming up as long as she keeps winning.



