Mike Francesa has never been one to mince words, and the legendary sports radio host is absolutely livid over Amazon's new Madden biopic. The film, starring Nicolas Cage as the iconic Oakland Raiders coach John Madden, has drawn the ire of Francesa, who knew Madden personally and interviewed him countless times over the years.
During his Wednesday show, Francesa let loose on the movie, calling it "painful" and "dreadful." He said, "This movie was painful. Painful. Probably more painful for me because I knew Madden well. I can hear John. I can think of funny things that happened in our interviews with John. I can think of things that happened through the years at the Super Bowl with John. And the bottom line is none of this comes through with Cage."
Francesa's frustration wasn't just about Cage's portrayal. He questioned the film's tone, saying, "You're not sure if they're trying to play it as a spoof or trying to make it into a cartoon. It just doesn't have any sense of realism. Its pacing is almost uncomfortable. It's dreadful. It is really that bad. I can't believe that somebody finished this and said, 'We got it'… A bunch of guys who know something about making movies and hopefully some guys who knew something about Madden and some guys who knew something about the NFL sat in a room, and they decided that this was good?"
The film, which chronicles Madden's journey from Super Bowl champion to the voice of football through his iconic video game, has been a critical disaster. As of Wednesday, only 20% of critic reviews on Rotten Tomatoes are positive. David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter wrote, "Even if I were passionate about pigskin, however, I can't imagine getting much pleasure from this cartoonish biodrama, led by the kind of stunt acting from both principals that never lets you forget they are Giving a Performance."
Brian Orndorf of Blu-ray.com also slammed the film for being as "frenzied and cartoonish as possible." Fans have already been predicting the movie would be a disaster, and their fears seem to have been realized. Cage's portrayal of Madden has been a particular sticking point, with many cringing at his John Madden impression.
Francesa's deep connection to Madden makes his critique especially stinging. He remembers the real man, not a caricature. "I can think of funny things that happened in our interviews with John," he said. "None of this comes through with Cage."
For those who want to see what all the fuss is about, Madden is streaming on Prime Video. But if you're looking for a coaching legend's story done right, you might want to look elsewhere.
Francesa's rant is a reminder that some stories are best told by those who lived them, not by Hollywood's interpretation. As he put it, this movie is "really that bad."



