The New York Giants have a decision to make in their backfield. Cam Skattebo has been a fan favorite since his debut in 2025, but the team's interest in acquiring Jonathan Taylor suggests they might be looking for an upgrade.
According to Jonathan Jones of The Athletic, the Giants are among the favorites to trade for the Indianapolis Colts' star running back. Taylor has been the engine of the Colts' offense since being drafted in 2020, amassing 8,185 rushing yards and 77 touchdowns. If he lands in New York, he would likely take over as the lead back, pushing Skattebo into a complementary role.
Skattebo's 2025 season has been a rollercoaster. He was benched in Week 6 after a costly overtime fumble against the Washington Commanders, but he bounced back with 124 rushing yards and a touchdown in a Week 7 win over the Houston Texans. Despite his 828 career rushing yards in 15 games, the Giants seem open to upgrading their running back room.
The potential addition of Taylor has sparked debate among fans. One fan tweeted, "If Taylor comes, it isn't to split carries. There is NO Thunder and Thunder. There is JT getting 80% of the work and Skattebo getting 20." Another compared the duo to a familiar NFL pairing: "Cam Skattebo is the Justice Hill to Jonathan Taylor's Derrick Henry. Skattebo is not the lead back in that scenario. And I think the Giants are ok with that."
Some fans see the logic in the move. "If you're drafting a 'bellcow' early in the draft, then trade the pick for Taylor is the easiest decision ever," one commenter wrote. "Taylor was a true blue chip prospect and people act like that just grows on trees."
While a one-two punch of Taylor and Skattebo could be formidable, it's clear Skattebo would need to accept a reduced role in the Giants' offense. After all, you don't mortgage draft picks to let someone else be the featured back.
NFL insider Ian Rapoport recently reported that the Colts are seeking a first-round pick for Taylor, but they might have to settle for a package of Day 2 picks. The 49ers' trade for Christian McCaffrey in 2022, which cost a second, third, fourth, and fifth-round pick, could serve as a template for the Giants.
As the trade deadline approaches, the Giants are weighing their options. Adding Taylor would be a bold statement of intent, signaling they're all-in on winning now. But it would also mean a significant shift in the pecking order, with Skattebo moving to a supporting role. For more on the latest trade buzz, check out Jonathan Taylor trade rumors.
If the Giants do pull the trigger, they'd be getting a proven workhorse who could immediately elevate their offense. But they'd also be betting that Taylor's best years are still ahead of him. It's a gamble that could pay off big, or it could backfire if Taylor's injury history becomes a factor. Either way, the Giants are clearly not satisfied with the status quo.



