The Indianapolis Colts' Thursday night showdown against the Houston Texans was a disaster on the field, but the real drama unfolded along the sideline. Owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon, notebook in hand, was a constant presence near the action, and her behavior is drawing heavy fire from fans and analysts alike.

Irsay-Gordon, who took over as principal owner in 2025, has made a habit of lingering near coaches and players during games, jotting down notes. It's a move that has sparked criticism before, but Thursday's 26-3 blowout loss amplified the backlash to a fever pitch.

Read also
NFL
Stroud's Stellar Season Sets Stage for Record-Breaking Deal
C.J. Stroud's bold decision to play out his contract is paying off, as the Texans are poised to offer him a record-breaking extension this offseason.

Former Colts quarterback Sean Salisbury didn't mince words when addressing the owner's sideline antics. "I told you when the season started when an owner stands on the sideline taking notes, you're f—–," Salisbury said. "I know people are going to focus on men or women, I don't care what the gender is …. I don't care if you're SpongeBob Squarepants. That is no place for the owner to be [on the sideline]. I have a lot of respect for the Irsays, I do. But the second you come downstairs during a game – not during the end – I'm telling you it's a disaster. … Players do not like to feel like they're being micro-managed."

The criticism was echoed across social media, with fans questioning the effectiveness and optics of her note-taking. "Does she even refer to her notes after games??? I'm beginning to think this is performative. Someone's gotta tell her to go to the box," one fan posted on X.

Another commenter added, "She could do that from a box, out of sight. But whether she knows it or doesn't care, it's awful for a player or coach to have the owner standing on the sideline taking notes furiously. It's causes unnecessary stress in what is already a tense environment."

Some fans drew parallels to workplace dynamics. "Having my employer breathe down my neck — every day, taking notes, while I'm trying to do my job — would probably make me go insane," one person wrote. "She's gotta stop this nonsense."

Others were simply baffled. "This gimmick would infuriate me if I were a Colts fan like what could she possibly be taking notes on," another fan asked.

Irsay-Gordon has defended her sideline presence, stating that the note-taking is part of her effort to deepen her understanding of the game. "I think one of the things that I learned in going through, even as back as when we hired Chuck Pagano (in 2012), is that sort of accelerated my, 'I need to learn more about this,'" she said in June 2025. "I need to be able to say, is this person full of BS? Do they even know what they're talking about? And I think one of the things that being on the headset has really helped me learn is to the question earlier, it's such a complex organism of football team and how it operates."

Despite the backlash, Irsay-Gordon shows no signs of retreating to the owner's suite. Her hands-on approach has become a defining trait of her ownership, but with the team spiraling and head coach Shane Steichen's job in jeopardy, the scrutiny is only intensifying.

The Colts' struggles have raised broader questions about the franchise's direction, with some already speculating about potential trades for quarterback Daniel Jones as the deadline looms. But for now, the spotlight remains fixed on the owner's sideline behavior, a distraction that many believe is doing more harm than good.

As the Colts look to regroup, one thing is clear: Irsay-Gordon's note-taking isn't just a quirk—it's become a lightning rod for criticism in a season that's quickly slipping away. Whether she'll adjust her approach remains to be seen, but the pressure is mounting for her to step back and let the coaches coach.