Harrison Butker's rough season took another ugly turn on Sunday, and Chiefs fans at Arrowhead Stadium let him hear it. The veteran kicker lined up for a 51-yard field goal on the final play of the first half against the New York Jets, and the kick had plenty of leg — but it drifted wide right. Boos rained down from the stands as the teams headed to the locker room.
It was the latest low point in what has become a historically frustrating year for Butker. Entering Sunday, he had connected on just 12 of 18 field goal tries, with five of those misses coming from beyond 50 yards. The miss against the Jets dropped him to 12 of 19, and his sixth miss from 50-plus yards.
The Chiefs came into the game as heavy favorites over a 2-6 Jets team, but they never managed to pull away. New York dominated time of possession, keeping Patrick Mahomes and company on the sideline. Kansas City's defense held strong in the red zone, forcing the Jets to settle for field goals, but the offense couldn't build a two-score cushion.
Social media erupted after Butker's miss, with fans offering a mix of frustration and dark humor. Some joked that he was still distracted by the midterm election results, given his well-known support for President Donald Trump. Others were less forgiving.
- "Wtf?? How many times are they going to send this kicker out to screw up? Bench him and put somebody else….." one user on X wrote.
- "He must still be distracted. I'm sure Tuesday night was really hard on him," another cracked.
- "Hopefully he's cut by 4 PM today," a third posted.
- "Butker missing on purpose so he can play GTA 6 [with] no distractions."
Through the first half of the season, the Chiefs have been lucky that their high-powered offense and stingy defense have masked Butker's inconsistencies. But as the games get tighter, the margin for error shrinks. Sunday's struggles against a struggling Jets team only amplify the concern.
Kansas City does have a potential fallback option already in the building: former All-Pro Justin Tucker, who is currently on the practice squad. Tucker was not elevated for Sunday's game, but the Chiefs have been standing by Butker despite his misses, though that patience may be wearing thin.
Meanwhile, the Chiefs' off-field storylines continue to draw attention, from Gracie Hunt's bachelorette festivities to accusations of cheating from opponents. But on Sunday, the loudest noise was reserved for Butker.
Can Butker redeem himself before the final whistle? Can he redeem himself at all? Those are the questions swirling around Arrowhead as the Chiefs try to hold off the Jets — and as their kicker tries to rediscover his form.



