The backlash against ESPN analyst Desmond Howard over his dismissal of Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith's Heisman Trophy candidacy continues to grow, with former Buckeyes linebacker Bobby Carpenter now joining the fray in emphatic fashion.

During last week's College GameDay, Howard questioned whether Smith had done enough in Ohio State's recent losses, a take that drew immediate fire from Buckeyes fans. But while social media erupted, some prominent alumni initially held their fire. Carpenter, however, waited until Monday's edition of his show to unleash a verbal barrage that left little doubt where he stands.

Read also
College Sports
Coaches' Poll Chaos: Week 13 Top 25 Drops After Shocking Upsets
The Week 13 Coaches' Poll is out with major shakeups after a wild Saturday of upsets. Ohio State, LSU, and Duke fell out, while several new teams entered the rankings.

“I don’t know if, like Desmond just doesn’t want another Ohio State guy to win the Heisman. It’s, it was gross. It was absolutely gross with his comments, and I’m glad RGIII stepped up and said something,” Carpenter said, echoing the criticism from Robert Griffin III, who was among the first to call out Howard on air.

Carpenter's frustration taps into a deeper sense of injustice among Buckeyes faithful. Since Troy Smith took home the Heisman in 2006, six Ohio State players have been finalists—Justin Fields, Chase Young, C.J. Stroud, Marvin Harrison Jr., Julian Sayin, and the late Dwayne Haskins—yet none have captured the trophy. For many, Howard's comments feel like yet another attempt to keep that streak alive.

The reaction from fans has been swift and unrelenting. In the comments section of Carpenter's post, supporters voiced their anger with a mix of bitterness and defiance. “Like all Michigan men Desmond has zero integrity. He doesn’t even try to hide his biased. Rich Eisen, Portney, Woodsen…. all the same. A bad tree doesn’t produce good fruit,” one wrote. Another declared, “He doesn’t want another Buckeye to win and he is using his ESPN platform to take shots at J Smith in an attempt to influence voters.” A third went further, calling for Howard's removal: “Desmond Howard should be fired a college football game day. He should not be voting for the Heisman.”

The controversy comes at a pivotal moment for Smith, who remains the betting favorite to win the Heisman despite the criticism. Barring an unforeseen collapse, he is expected to be on stage in New York City next month for the ceremony. But Howard's words could still linger in the minds of voters, especially with the criticism of his critique continuing to spread across sports media.

Carpenter's strong stance also highlights a broader issue: the perceived bias among ESPN analysts who are alumni of rival programs. Howard, a Michigan legend, has long been accused of favoring his alma mater, and this latest episode has only intensified that narrative. Some fans have even pointed to officiating controversies in Big Ten games as further evidence of systemic bias against Ohio State.

Yet, Smith has responded on the field all season, and his numbers speak for themselves. His record-breaking performances have silenced many doubters, and he remains on pace to etch his name in Buckeyes lore. Whether Howard's comments will sway Heisman voters remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Ohio State fans are not about to let this go quietly.

As the season winds down and the Heisman vote approaches, the question lingers: Will Desmond Howard's harsh words have any impact on the outcome? For Carpenter and countless Buckeyes supporters, the hope is that voters will look past the noise and recognize Smith's undeniable talent.