ESPN analyst Desmond Howard has once again sparked controversy with his comments about Ohio State, this time drawing widespread criticism for his take on star wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. During Friday's edition of First Take, Howard questioned Smith's impact in big games, despite the receiver's impressive statistics and crucial role in the Buckeyes' national championship run.
Howard, a former Michigan standout, suggested that Smith's numbers don't tell the full story. "You got to have those moments," Howard said. "In the last two seasons, when was Jeremiah Smith the difference in a big game? Give me that game. As much as he puts up these magnificent numbers, I need moments against the top competition that shows he's the guy."
The reaction was swift and fierce. Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer called the criticism "really old" and said it's hard to take seriously. Fans and analysts alike pointed to specific instances where Smith delivered when it mattered most, including a standout performance against Miami and a 40-yard touchdown at Michigan in a tied game on fourth down. One fan noted, "Smith is our offense. He goes out, we are basically a crap version of Iowa."
Smith's Resume Speaks for Itself
Since arriving at Ohio State in 2024, Smith has been nothing short of spectacular. As a freshman, he was instrumental in the Buckeyes' national title victory, hauling in 76 passes for 1,315 yards and 15 touchdowns. This season, he's continued to shine with 69 catches for 1,200 yards and 14 touchdowns, bringing his career totals to an astonishing 3,758 receiving yards.
Despite Howard's skepticism, ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. has Smith firmly at the top of his 2027 NFL Draft board. "I think that's pretty much locked in," Kiper said. "You write that in pen. He's a great player. We've seen it since the freshman year where we would have probably had him in our top three to five overall big board, maybe a little higher."
Howard's History with Ohio State
This isn't the first time Howard has been accused of bias against Ohio State. His comments have often drawn the ire of Buckeyes fans, who see a pattern of negativity. One fan pointed out the contrast with other Michigan alums in the media: "At least Charles Woodson and Jake Butt are professional on air."
The criticism of Howard's latest remarks also echoes broader conversations about media coverage of Ohio State and its players. While some analysts are willing to offer balanced takes, others seem to let personal rivalries color their analysis. This ongoing tension has become a recurring theme in college football coverage, as seen in reactions to Ryan Day's coaching and Smith's response to his critics.
What's Next for Smith?
Smith will have another opportunity to silence doubters when Ohio State hosts Northwestern on Sunday. If his past performances are any indication, he's more than capable of delivering the kind of "moment" Howard claims he lacks. For now, the debate continues, but Smith's on-field production speaks volumes.
As the season progresses, all eyes will be on Smith to see if he can continue his dominant play and lead the Buckeyes to another title. For Howard, the backlash serves as a reminder that criticism without context often falls flat, especially when directed at a player with Smith's proven track record.



