The New Orleans Saints entered the 2026 season with cautious optimism, but the shine has worn off Tyler Shough and this offense. What began as a promising rookie campaign has devolved into a concerning slump, and the calls for change are growing louder.

Shough, selected 40th overall in the 2025 NFL Draft, started his career with a respectable 5-4 record across nine starts. He completed 67.6% of his passes for 2,384 yards, tossing 10 touchdowns against six interceptions. Those numbers hinted at a bright future, but the last three games have told a different story.

Read also
NFL
Stroud's Stellar Season Sets Stage for Record-Breaking Deal
C.J. Stroud's bold decision to play out his contract is paying off, as the Texans are poised to offer him a record-breaking extension this offseason.

ESPN analyst Ben Solak didn't hold back in his critique of the second-year signal-caller this week. Solak highlighted that Shough ranks 24th in EPA per dropback and 37th in explosive pass rate, but the most damning stat came from Week 10's loss to the Carolina Panthers: 40% of Shough's pass attempts were behind the line of scrimmage. That conservative approach has neutered the Saints' passing attack and made them predictable.

“If Shough cannot connect on deep balls and does not attack the intermediate area of the field, he cannot create the chunk gains necessary to hold down a starting quarterback job in the league,” Solak wrote. He went on to suggest that the Saints must begin scouting the 2027 quarterback class, warning that Shough's grip on the starting job is slipping. “Perhaps my eyes are on the wrong target, and Kellen Moore will get the heat for the lack of a running game — a justifiable frustration. But then Shough will enter the 2027 season much as Penix entered the 2026 season: with an uncertain hold on a starting job, and perhaps a veterans minimum addition like Tua Tagovailoa meant to challenge him in training camp. The quarterback hurt the offense in the must-win against the Panthers and has kept their passing game far too meek through 10 weeks of this season. Something needs to change, fast.”

The Saints' ground game hasn't done Shough any favors. He's currently the team's leading rusher with 187 yards, a telling indictment of a rushing attack that has sputtered regardless of whether Alvin Kamara, Travis Etienne, Audric Estime, or Kendre Miller lines up in the backfield. The lack of balance has made the offense one-dimensional and easier to defend.

Slow starts have also plagued the Saints under head coach Kellen Moore. In fact, New Orleans has trailed in all 26 games with Moore at the helm — a staggering statistic that underscores the team's inability to seize control early. The offense's sluggishness has put pressure on the defense and forced Shough into comeback mode far too often.

As the Saints prepare for their Week 11 showdown with the Chicago Bears, the pressure is mounting. A loss could all but end their playoff hopes, and the front office may be forced to accelerate their quarterback search. Recent history shows that officiating changes can impact games, but the Saints' problems run deeper than any zebra call.

Meanwhile, the Bears have their own quarterback questions, and Baker Mayfield recently accused them of illegal cadence mimicry in a narrow loss. Whether that controversy lingers remains to be seen, but New Orleans can't rely on distractions — they need Shough to step up and prove he's the long-term answer.

With the 2027 draft class already generating buzz, the Saints have a decision to make. Do they stick with Shough and hope he develops, or do they start exploring alternatives? Solak's warning is clear: the status quo isn't working. Sunday's game against the Bears could be a defining moment for Shough's tenure in New Orleans.