Even with the NFL Draft looming, ESPN star Laura Rutledge knows how to prioritize what matters. This week, she proved that family comes first by orchestrating an unforgettable 37th birthday celebration for her husband, former MLB infielder Josh Rutledge, that has fans talking—and drooling.
While Rutledge is preparing for a primetime role alongside Mike Greenberg for ESPN's coverage of the 2026 NFL Draft from Pittsburgh, she carved out time Monday for a personal milestone. The popular host treated her husband to what can only be described as a pizza pilgrimage through New Haven, Connecticut, documenting the entire flavorful adventure on her Instagram Story.
A Slice of Heaven for a Birthday Boy
Forget the fancy dinners or extravagant gifts. The Rutledges opted for a culinary quest, hitting three of New Haven's most hallowed pizza institutions in one night. This wasn't just a meal; it was a tribute to a regional style revered by pizza aficionados worldwide.
Their tour kicked off at the legendary Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, the century-old birthplace of New Haven's iconic coal-fired, thin-crust pizza. From there, the couple navigated to the equally famous Sally's Apizza on Wooster Street. The lines were so formidable they enjoyed their 'Calabrian Stinger' pie—loaded with salami, nduja, peppers, and hot honey—from the comfort of their car.
The birthday feast culminated at BAR, a newer but beloved spot, where they dug into the meat-lover's dream, 'The Carnivore,' featuring smoked brisket, meatball, and pepperoni.
Why New Haven Pizza Reigns Supreme
While New York often grabs the pizza headlines, true connoisseurs frequently point to New Haven as the undisputed champion. The city's signature style—characterized by its blistery, charred crust from coal-fired ovens and minimalist, high-quality toppings—has earned a cult-like following. It's a distinct and delicious experience that separates it from any other pie in the country.
This sweet birthday gesture shows a different side of the broadcaster, who is typically in the spotlight for major sports events like the NFL Draft. It's a relatable and heartwarming glimpse into her life off-camera, celebrating a personal victory with her partner of nine years.
Josh Rutledge, who played for the Colorado Rockies and Boston Red Sox between 2012 and 2017, certainly seemed to approve of the unique birthday present. The tour was a perfect blend of low-key fun and high-quality food, proving you don't need flash to create a memorable celebration.
As Rutledge shifts gears back to her professional duties, including her high-profile NFL Draft coverage, this pizza-fueled birthday bash serves as a delicious reminder that even sports media stars cherish simple, slice-of-life moments with their loved ones.
