College football fans are collectively shaking their heads after ESPN's computer model released its latest Top 25, and somehow, Ohio State is still sitting pretty at No. 6. Yes, you read that right. The same Buckeyes team that just fell to 7-4 with a gut-wrenching loss at Nebraska is being ranked ahead of teams with far better résumés.

The Buckeyes' hopes of a Big Ten title and a College Football Playoff berth went up in smoke on Saturday, as Nebraska pulled off a stunning upset in Lincoln. It was a crushing defeat for Ohio State, and head coach Ryan Day didn't mince words afterward.

Read also
College Sports
Coaches' Poll Chaos: Week 13 Top 25 Drops After Shocking Upsets
The Week 13 Coaches' Poll is out with major shakeups after a wild Saturday of upsets. Ohio State, LSU, and Duke fell out, while several new teams entered the rankings.

“When you watch a game like this, you have a lot of things that have to change, and not going to jump anything right now because we have a game we got to play in another week, so like always, we have to evaluate what’s going on, and we’ll do that. But this game right here, when you see the third downs converted, especially in the first half, and then you see some of the plays that they made against us, it certainly cost us. The offense goes down, scores with just under four minutes to go, and got an opportunity to fight back in it all the way at the end, and hit us with a couple plays that we had seen throughout the game and weren’t able to get off the field. So that was extremely frustrating, and that ultimately cost us the game,” Day said in his postgame press conference.

Despite that performance, ESPN's Football Power Index (FPI)—a metric designed to predict future success—still has the Buckeyes ranked sixth in the nation. The model, which simulates the rest of the season 20,000 times, clearly sees something in Ohio State that the eye test doesn't. But fans aren't buying it.

Outspoken sports personality Clay Travis was among the first to call out the absurdity. “I’m not a data expert, but if @espn’s FPI has Ohio State at six and LSU at nine, you gotta burn down your entire formula and start over from scratch,” he posted on social media.

He wasn't alone. Fans flooded the internet with their own takes, many pointing out that Iowa, which just went 9-2 with one of the best defenses in the country, is ranked 16th—10 spots behind Ohio State. “The formula is just helmet stickers,” one fan wrote. Another joked, “OSU could be 0-12 and still in the top 25 lol.”

Even the most generous observer might struggle to justify Ohio State's placement. The Buckeyes have lost four games, and their defense has been exposed time and again. But ESPN's FPI is a prediction-based model, not a résumé ranking. As ESPN explains, “The Football Power Index (FPI) is a measure of team strength that is meant to be the best predictor of a team’s performance going forward for the rest of the season. FPI represents how many points above or below average a team is. Projected results are based on 20,000 simulations of the rest of the season using FPI, results to date, and the remaining schedule.”

Still, that explanation hasn't quelled the backlash. For many, the ranking feels like a slap in the face to teams that have actually won games. And it's not just Ohio State's placement that's raising eyebrows—it's the entire list. The Huskers' celebration after breaking a 10-year skid against Ohio State adds salt to the wound, as fans point out that Nebraska's victory should have dropped the Buckeyes further.

Some are even calling for a complete overhaul of the FPI formula, arguing that it relies too heavily on preseason expectations and recruiting stars rather than on-field results. The controversial non-challenge by Ryan Day late in the game didn't help matters, either, as it may have cost Ohio State a chance to tie the game.

As the regular season winds down, Ohio State will look to salvage what's left of their campaign, but the damage is done. And while the FPI might still believe in the Buckeyes, the court of public opinion has already rendered its verdict: this ranking is a joke.

For now, ESPN's computer model remains unapologetic, but the outcry is loud and clear. If the FPI wants to be taken seriously, it might need to reconsider what it values most. After all, in the world of college football, wins and losses should still matter—especially when the losses keep piling up.