The Luke Fahey era at Ohio State has begun, and it's off to a rocky start. With Julian Sayin sidelined by an injury, the true freshman is making his first career start against USC, and through the first quarter-plus, the Buckeyes' offense has sputtered. After three drives, Ohio State has just two field goals to show for it, and the defense has been gashed, allowing the Trojans to race out to a 14-3 lead.
Fahey's first drive nearly ended in disaster when a pass intended for Jeremiah Smith was almost picked off by a USC defender, only for the call to be overturned by the slimmest of margins. The early jitters are understandable for a quarterback who had thrown just 13 passes in his career before today. Through his first nine attempts, he's completed six for 81 yards—decent numbers, but not enough to put points on the board when it matters.
What's really got Buckeye Nation riled up isn't just the scoreboard, though. It's the play-calling. Fans are already questioning whether offensive coordinator Chip Kelly and head coach Ryan Day trust Fahey's arm, and the conservative approach has them worried about the rest of the season. One frustrated fan took to X to voice their concerns: "It has absolutely nothing to do with the scoreboard, but I am very, VERY worried. The play calls alone make me think that even with the extra week we had, they do not trust Fahey's arm. I don't either. Please prove me wrong, Luke. I've never wanted to be wrong so bad in my life."
But while Fahey is taking the brunt of the criticism, many fans are quick to point out that the defense is the real problem. USC needed just nine plays to score two touchdowns, and the Buckeyes' defensive unit, coordinated by Matt Patricia, has looked lost. Another fan didn't hold back: "Luke Fahey might be (expletive), but he doesn't play defense….absolutely no excuse for this defensive disasterclass from Matt Patricia. Fireable offense IMO."
The sentiment is echoed by others who see the bigger picture. "Luke Fahey not even playing bad… defense and special teams playing like (expletive)," wrote a third fan. The frustration is palpable, but so is the fear that this could be a long season if the defense doesn't get its act together.
Some fans are already calling for a change in recruiting philosophy, harking back to the days of dual-threat quarterbacks. "Luke Fahey is not HIM!! When have we stopped recruiting real dual threat quarterbacks? We have to get back to that asap!! Ryan day tryna change (expletive), bra get with the program or you will be fired within 2 years. We natty boys, not runner ups!"
Ohio State hasn't lost a regular-season Big Ten game since the 2024 loss to Michigan, and the pressure is on to keep that streak alive. But with an unranked USC team coming into Columbus and taking control early, the Buckeyes are in danger of an upset. Rightly or wrongly, Fahey is going to be the one blamed if they can't pull off a comeback.
As the game continues on NBC, all eyes are on the freshman signal-caller. Can he shake off the nerves and lead the Buckeyes back? Or will this be a day that Ohio State fans want to forget? One thing's for sure: they've already made up their minds about Luke Fahey, and it's going to take a whole lot of second-half magic to change them.



